We haven’t done one of these in awhile, so why not? McKinley was the Expos’ first choice in the 1998 draft, so big things were expected of the guy. It seems he was a pretty well-regarded amateur player who played with Austin Kearns and Michael Cuddyer in the 1997 World Junior Championships. Unfortunately, it seems that he couldn’t hit in the minors. At all. His highest OPS was a SLG-heavy .834 in 2003.
He never made the majors, and was retired by age 24. So, yeah, a wasted pick. Oh, and I also have the chrome version of this card: